logo Sign In

Post #121505

Author
MagnoliaFan
Parent topic
Info: MagnoliaFan on MF.com
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/121505/action/topic#121505
Date created
6-Jul-2005, 10:40 PM
Quote

Originally posted by: Shimraa
ok guys i just finished balance, it was fantastic good job magnolia, i did not see one editing error in there and usually i am very good at picking those out whne i try. I relaly liked how your put so much into improvign the back story of why the trade federation attacked and so on, also the extra stuff on curocant was great. just one problem with the whole thing, you shouldnt have taken out the mediclorians idea, cause that is key in ep3. i know people say well it messes with the idea of the force being so mystical, i personally dont think it does, we all know that there are some people who just cant use the force, Han for example, something i think most people miss is that just cause mediclorians are there does not mean they are the force, they dont create the force they mearly interact with it, and it was this interaction that gives jedi's the ability to use the force. see what i am saying. anyway overall it was fantastic, i loved jar jar he moved from being most hated to on my top ten list after that movie. also the dubbing was a splended idea, i am interested in seeing what you did with AOTC cause i know that with better editing that movie could have been as good if not better then ANH, and ROTS.


Thanks, Shimraa. Glad you enjoyed it.
Although the midichlorians are out, I kept the basic theme the same, just simplified. Plagueis could manipulate the force to create life, stop people from dying, etc.
Consider what you see on EP II a work in progress. Neither Balance or Clone War was initially intended for release, they merely got pirated by someone who had access to a copy, so I allowed Rikter to distribute them freely. My Episode II was much less complete in my eyes than Episode I.
I'm soon going to release a DVD+R DL disc of it that contains a slightly updated version of the film, an extended version, and a few other viewing customization options.
I'm just waiting to get back a few completed shots that I subbed out to other people, so that I can finish it up.