rey is extremely charismatic and a very likeable character overall. she has some very interesting stuff that she has to figure out about herself that would make her an awesome character. unfortunately she suffers from overpoweredness, which makes me lose my interest in her and even find her annoying. (plus i don’t think she’s well written in tfa)

jyn is likeable even though she’s not an active protagonist and while she has somewhat of an arc it’s not a very well developed one (even though i quite liked it and thought it was very compelling) which ends up hurting RO a lot.

cassian imo is the most interesting character in RO: he had lost himself in the war and ends up finding his way back to the light with jyn, i think. i should rewatch the movie, but i remember cassian being a well developed character.

sure if you like rey she’s a much better character than the other two. objectively she’s miles ahead from any of them. but i dislike rey, so, to me, rogue one’s characters are far better.