I think both Shopping Maul and ZkinandBonez make good points , the Tarkin story was a better way of making something like a second death star without making a carbon copy of it .Although, Michellinie’s first pitch for the story was a literal second Death Star and Lucasfilm put the brakes on it for obvious reasons , so he invented the Tarkin superweapon instead .I also thought it should have been a longer arc. And , ZkinandBones , that Doomorld dvd cover is pure awesome sauce ! I want to see it in animated form or at least a motion comic now ! I also had not considered how the source material each comic series drew from had changed .I will always prefer the original though, but you make some valid points.