The quality of Rogue One has only gone down for me. The lifeless characters and boring story direction they took sours the experience of an otherwise visually impressive film.
That’s funny because I had the exact opposite reaction. In theaters I couldn’t remember anyone’s name and didn’t find anything compelling about anyone other than Chirrut, Baze, and sort of Krennic. Since then I’ve grown much more attached to the other characters.
I like RO more and more each time I see it. And I loved it in the theater. TFA was the same way at first, though it found a peak and leveled out a little below that peak. My assessment of TLJ hasn’t changed with subsequent viewings.