Ok but “Luke becomes a hermit” is entirely on TFA’s docket.
I agree, I should have better phrased my argument. I like Luke’s arc, but I feel it requires too much of a leap in logic for Luke to become the type of hermit he is in TLJ.
In all honesty, I do think I now agree with this. The jump of logic is hard for me to accept but once I buy into it, the arc works really well.