logo Sign In

Post #1207163

Author
Ryan-SWI
Parent topic
Movie Preservation and Home Media: An Opinion
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1207163/action/topic#1207163
Date created
17-May-2018, 7:21 AM

fmalover said:

from changes in colour timing to stuff like DNR and edge enhancement

I feel like DNR is this generation’s Pan & Scan.

Consumers are annoyed at the black bars and less image? Make it fill the screen.

Consumers don’t like how dirty the image looks? Digitally clean it.

The unfortunate truth is that the majority of consumers don’t care about having the truest master of the original version of the film, but rather what looks the “best”, even if it’s monumentally worse in doing so.

Ronster said:

This is why I like DVD so much still to this day.

Nothing had to be re-created as you say.

Are we talking about modifications from the original DCP to home media? Because I can name plenty of DVDs that suffered similar issues plaguing BDs, like DNR. Prime example given the website; The Phantom Menace.

fmalover said:

Just like there are some purists who will only listen to music on vinyl records

Unfortunately vinyl pressings can also have somewhat similar issues as A/V home media transfers, but that’s a bit off topic 😉