logo Sign In

Post #1186753

Author
Shopping Maul
Parent topic
The Last Jedi: Official Review and Opinions Thread ** SPOILERS **
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1186753/action/topic#1186753
Date created
23-Mar-2018, 3:14 AM

SilverWook said:

This is the same council who poo pooed that the idea the Sith had returned, never mind what Qui-Gon had to report, took a army of clones without seriously questioning who actually commissioned it, and even when tipped off by Dooku, (who they insisted would never try to kill a senator) never suspected Palpatine of being a Sith lord until it was too late. Not the brightest bunch of bulbs in the chandelier. šŸ˜›

No argument there ha ha! But, in terms of training Jedi and vetting Midichlorian-rich children, they had at least been doing this for a long time without noticeable fallout. Otherwise, like I said, there would be scores of self-trained Dark Siders running around Force-choking people and generating enough of a psychic ā€˜rippleā€™ to bring the council to attention.

To use my previous X-Men analogy, if Charles Xavier didnā€™t take on mutant kids, they would then be at risk of a) having no control over their powers and destroying their own lives and b) being recruited into Magnetoā€™s brotherhood. But with Midichlorian-kids itā€™s clear that, if left alone, they pose no threat. Otherwise the Jedi Order would snap them all up on principle. So it follows that training is the key in the SW universe, at least as I see it.