You lost me at “scientific perspective.”
It’s not even necessary to invoke science. Logic will do just fine. Fantasy movies do not have to adhere to science, but they have to make logical sense in-universe.
True, that’s exactly why I’m okay with it.
Funny, it’s why I’m not. It’s not the worst of TLJ’s offenses in my view, and it’s a stunning visual moment in the film, but it sadly fits with what I percieve to be RJ’s general disregard for the in-universe rules established by Lucas over the last four decades.
I’m not at which point in the previous six Lucas films they establish that this isn’t possible, but whatever.
I think NeverarGreat made very clear, why it is somewhat of an issue for some of us, but since you stopped reading after the “scientific perspective” part, you probably missed the point he was making, but whateverrrrrr…
Having read it now, I don’t think that’s really the case, but whatever.
(also, when I say “whatever,” I don’t say it in that valley girl way, it’s basically just a shortening of “whatever you say, if that’s how you want to view it,” but whatever)