Understandable, and I think Adywan is on the same page as you for ANH:R:HD. I might just do my own version of the audio track with the March inserted for myself.
It’s not that I don’t think it fits - the imperial march fits perfectly imo for the Death Star reveal - but it takes away from the first time we hear it in ESB.
Regarding Battle of the Heroes, I don’t really think it fits at all.
I actually agree with both of these, but in the context of the entire saga (yes, even the prequels…) it’s odd that the March is completely absent from Episode IV.
I disagree, but I understand.
PT is my guilty pleasure and I tend to rewatch them every year, so I’d be one to notice that, but I don’t. I guess I’ve gotten used to SW without imperial march or something like that. I don’t know, I just don’t miss it. Vader’s not THAT important in the movie as in the other 5, so I guess there’s a reason for you.
Also, if you watch the saga in release order it ends up making sense and new viewers won’t even notice or remember that it was absent from the movie, I don’t think. Heck, I only realized that the the march wasn’t in it hours before TFA’s opening night, when I marathoned the OT.
Not only that, but I’m pretty sure Revisited is, for all intents and purposes, only a trilogy now 😃