logo Sign In

Star Wars Episode I: Cloak Of Deception (Released) — Page 19

Author
Time

Is there any place that we could find the newest versions of “Cloak Of Deception”, “The Approaching Storm”, and “Labyrinth Of Evil”? The newest version is V5, right?

Author
Time

ChiefWamsutta said:

Is there any place that we could find the newest versions of “Cloak Of Deception”, “The Approaching Storm”, and “Labyrinth Of Evil”? The newest version is V5, right?

V5 is not out yet, the newest versions are 4.2. You can check a Reddit post by Hal in r/fanedits and you’ll find what you’re looking for. Or pm him 😄

Author
Time
 (Edited)

Collipso said:

ChiefWamsutta said:

Is there any place that we could find the newest versions of “Cloak Of Deception”, “The Approaching Storm”, and “Labyrinth Of Evil”? The newest version is V5, right?

V5 is not out yet, the newest versions are 4.2. You can check a Reddit post by Hal in r/fanedits and you’ll find what you’re looking for. Or pm him 😄

Thanks friend. 😃 I actually already have those versions. : P Just wondering if I missed a version.

Author
Time

Hal 9000 said:

mierdonardo said:

Is there some way to get the Spanish subtitles of this and/or your other PT edits? Or at least the English subtitles in an independent file so I can translate it myself.

I suggest you PM MalàStrana, who created the subtitles. I am currently working on a final version of these three edits, and he is planning to do subtitles for those as well. I can’t speak for his workflow for this, but it may be that he could provide you with finished (synced) English subtitles and you could translate these to Spanish. That would be a welcome addition to this final version, if you are willing.
So far I have sent him a screener for Episode III so he can sync the subtitles, with Episodes I and II coming after.

Just as a quick note (absolutely love your PT, by the way). When Qui-Gon is talking to Shmi Skywalker about Anakin having special powers and who the father was, there is a very subtle moment when you can hear C3PO saying the word ‘Master Anakin’.

Author
Time

Yeah, V5 is not out yet. It’s in progress, and is intended as FINAL.

About Threepio saying “Master Anakin,” that’s fine. It’s just that 3PO was “built by” Anakin that I tried to take the emphasis off of. (Head canon is that 3PO was built over 100 years BBY and Anakin found him all torn apart and fixed him up.)

My stance on revising fan edits.

Author
Time

Hal 9000 said:

Yeah, V5 is not out yet. It’s in progress, and is intended as FINAL.

About Threepio saying “Master Anakin,” that’s fine. It’s just that 3PO was “built by” Anakin that I tried to take the emphasis off of. (Head canon is that 3PO was built over 100 years BBY and Anakin found him all torn apart and fixed him up.)

This and Boba being Jango’s son are enough reasons for why someone should watch your versions over theatrical. Objectively infinitely better movies too.

Author
Time
 (Edited)

(Head canon is that 3PO was built over 100 years BBY and Anakin found him all torn apart and fixed him up.)

I think it’s more or less the current canon.

Author
Time

Collipso said:
This and Boba being Jango’s son are enough reasons for why someone should watch your versions over theatrical. Objectively infinitely better movies too.

Boba, clone or not, he’s still the son of Jango 😃 (in both case he’s even the biological son of Jango)

Author
Time

MalàStrana said:

Collipso said:
This and Boba being Jango’s son are enough reasons for why someone should watch your versions over theatrical. Objectively infinitely better movies too.

Boba, clone or not, he’s still the son of Jango 😃 (in both case he’s even the biological son of Jango)

It’s less weird this way and we can get rid of Morrison in ESB without messing up canon.

Author
Time

stickydixon said:

I second LordPlagueis’ recommendation of removing the “battle hardened” droids line. How does more combat help a droid? I don’t think they gain experience.

Well, in real life, machine learning has actually been quite big deal recently in AI development.

Author
Time

Dr. Krogshöj said:

stickydixon said:

I second LordPlagueis’ recommendation of removing the “battle hardened” droids line. How does more combat help a droid? I don’t think they gain experience.

Well, in real life, machine learning has actually been quite big deal recently in AI development.

In Star Wars droids learn too, of course. If I’m not mistaken the battle droids in Episode I didn’t have individual minds but were controlled by a Central Control Computer and thus they were all equally experienced. It’s possible that the “main AI” was “battle hardened” through the experience of each droid.

Author
Time

Sir Ridley said:

Dr. Krogshöj said:

stickydixon said:

I second LordPlagueis’ recommendation of removing the “battle hardened” droids line. How does more combat help a droid? I don’t think they gain experience.

Well, in real life, machine learning has actually been quite big deal recently in AI development.

In Star Wars droids learn too, of course. If I’m not mistaken the battle droids in Episode I didn’t have individual minds but were controlled by a Central Control Computer and thus they were all equally experienced. It’s possible that the “main AI” was “battle hardened” through the experience of each droid.

Valid points you two, but it just seems out of place nonetheless.

Author
Time

Probably but sometimes you cut a line that is not bad nor really problematic and you end up having a noticeable jarring audio cut. An issues often “heard” in many fanedits that tend to cut too much, even the slightest word.

Author
Time

Or sometimes you get multiple streams synced that multiple people are working on and encode them all and have them ready to go and new ideas have to be declined. Lol
It’d be an okay change to make, but I’m afraid things are locked down at this point. COD V5 exists, and I’ll get it to you all soon as I am able. I will not be able to upload it for a while, and hopefully by then TAS and LOE will be able to join it.

My stance on revising fan edits.

Author
Time

Is this the absolute final version? If so can I get the download? Also is there an edit of the 2nd movie too?

Author
Time

Nihilus137 said:

Is this the absolute final version? If so can I get the download? Also is there an edit of the 2nd movie too?

This is part of a PT edit series. The current version seems to be the “definitive” version according to Hal. It’s not out yet but soon will be. There are older versions, but I suggest you wait for the final version

Author
Time

By the way, it hasn’t been said here but the final version of this edit is available somewhere over the spleen 😃

Author
Time

Version 5 is on spleen now? Or the version before?

“Because you are a PalpaWalker?”