I agree as well. The special editions should have just been the most extensive clean up of the films ever, removing matte lines and all that but not actually adding any special effects and/or scenes.

that would make a nice (the perfect?) 6 disc set. first 3 discs a nice cleaned up set of the OOT, no changes, just special effects tweaked to remove any technical "glitches" as RowMan so nicely called them. and the second 3 discs to have pretty much straight transfers of the films that were shown in theaters when the movies were first released (id even say the cleaned up version has the ANH in the crawl, and the uncleaned version have just the original crawl, but maybe a selectable crawl)

-Darth Simon