Ok. Just trying to see if there is any correlation between number of viewings and impression of that scene. I hope that didn’t seem like a rude question.
I didn’t have very strong feelings on the direction of that scene the first time. I didn’t like that it seemed like they were going to kill him off and I thought that Rose’s reason for stopping him was lame. On balance, I prefer that he survived. The second time around I didn’t have the annoyance of “oh…they’re really going to kill him,” and then “just kidding!”