I maintain my position that website biographies, novelizations, screenplays, etc. are inadmissible and all that matters is what was on the screen.
With that said, I don’t think there’s much question that Rey “won” that fight. Which I’m fine with given Kylo’s condition at the time.
I’m fine with it too. The screenplay does speak for the intentions of the creators, and proofs that it’s not just some random interpretation of a few fans trying to push their own narrative. Once we’ve established what the creator’s intended, we can discuss if that translated well to the screen.