Difficult topic to discuss really, as our opinions are subjective. I know a good deal of people who are Star Wars fans, and none of us agree with each other on topics like this.

But in general I sympathies with the idea and often lament that the sequel trilogy didn’t appear 20 years ago. Also I don’t know anyone who doesn’t imagine what might have been in such a scenario, I thought everyone did it.

Shadows of the Empire could have been made a film in 95/96. Loved Zahn’s survivor’s quest, hand of thrawn and outbound flight.

For the record, loved Rouge One, can’t stand the PT (would watch the two Ewok movies over these), don’t care for the current ST (i.e not what I personally imagined or wanted), and loved Alien 3, (director’s cut over the cinema release).

Basically, there’s no accounting for taste!