logo Sign In

Post #1148382

Author
Ryan
Parent topic
The Last Jedi: Official Review and Opinions Thread ** SPOILERS **
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1148382/action/topic#1148382
Date created
25-Dec-2017, 1:05 AM

Collipso said:

I think some of the criticism that’s been directed at TLJ should be directed at TFA instead. TFA set up its sequels with having to answer so many questions that should’ve been answered by TFA itself. It worked as a first part in a two parter, and it should’ve been a standalone film to set things up, like Star Wars and even The Phantom Menace were.
One example is Snoke and the First Order. Why not just tell us how he rose to power and how the First Order came to be in TFA? Why leave it to the other movies? But no, screw it. TFA shouldn’t have left a mystery box for the other movies to fill.

This is a good reason why if say this ST was around the new Jedi Temple with Luke training new Jedi. Then looking at that compared to ROTJ, we wouldn’t need an explanation with how the Jedi Temple was created, etc.

Where as, based on what we saw in ROTJ, we really need explanation for how the First Order, Snoke, and the new Storm Troopers came about.