Alright so I’m going to be that guy. I’ve been watching the Star Wars films the past few days (as one does at a time like this) and you can I guess chalk it up to childhood nostalgia, but, in all honesty I enjoyed ROTS better than RO (neither fan edited, mind you). There is no doubt in my mind that ROTS is the worse film, and I still rank it that way, but I just find it in many ways more interesting and engaging than RO (even if its mistakes make me even more angry). That old thing about a strong reaction vs. an indifferent reaction I suppose.
Just makes me excited to get back to my ROTS edit when I get the chance.