I agree that the cuts in and of themselves are all very smooth, I just feel that they move too fast as films. I’ve not seen the film unedited in 10 years or so I’d say.

Re:octorox. Basically a hybrid of q2, Hal, and l8wrtr with a few original edits. They move brisk but aren’t too fast. Mainly conservative as far as plot structure is concerned. Keeps original names. Episode 2 has an original music montage for Anakin and padme falling in love to replace dialogue and I think it works pretty well. No ep 3 yet. Only real complaint is there are one or two things in each that were cut that didn’t hurt anything being in there that I would have left just to relax the pace a tad and the video quality, while pretty good, could be slightly better. The highest video quality versions clock in around 17 gb, I think fluffing it out to around 19 or 20 could have been beneficial, especially since this is likely at least a 3rd generation re encode for much of it seeing as it uses hals video for much of the base since it was slightly regraded and was probably reencoded again from that unless he used an editor with smart rendering. Don’t get me wrong though it still looks very good.