For this entire edit replace the audio so use all of this of course ask for permission
For a new hope ask Harmy if you could use Harmy respecalized audio track
For empire make your own using harmys despecialized 2.0 and the Blu-Ray
For Jedi use Harmy despecialized 2.5 and the Blu-rayDo it So the audio doesn’t sound bad
Um…no.
First off, Harmy used the theatrical 1977 audio. This is the 1997 Special Edition. They don’t sync.
Second off, Poita is using the theatrical DTS audio - as in, the exact same audio you would have heard in a theater with DTS sound instead of Dolby in 1997 - which is by many accounts the best-sounding mix of Star Wars out there, SE changes notwithstanding.
JEDIT: Just saw that you said “Respecialized.” For that, Harmy used the 1997 Laserdisc Dolby Digital audio. If I’m not mistaken, the DTS discs that Poita is using are higher quality and are already designed to sync to the film reels he’s using. Plus, they’re the same mix as the LD audio Harmy used.
Ok I thought it would sound better so it doesn’t sound like 20 year old film second
I still think he should recreate the audio for empire and Jedi
Why would he need to recreate anything if he has access to A) the optical stereo audio on the film itself and B) the theatrical DTS discs for the movies? And this isn’t about updating it to make it seem like it was just made. It is 20 years old, it should sound like it did 20 years ago, just like any restoration of the 1977 version (Harmy’s included) should sound like it did 40 years ago.