logo Sign In

Post #1123282

Author
NeverarGreat
Parent topic
Anyone else totally disregard Leia being Luke's sister?
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1123282/action/topic#1123282
Date created
29-Oct-2017, 11:45 PM

ToscheStation said:

What I’ll never understand is how someone can find a story as “rich”, “expansive”, and overall “emotionally satisfying”, a version of the Star Wars universe where:

  1. The main character’s parents were people that we’ve never seen or met, and will probably never get to see, barring prequels.

  2. The princess character belongs to a family that (thanks to the Death Star) we’ve never met, nor whom we will ever learn about in potential sequels.

  3. A solitary knight(Ben) with no family or progeny whatsoever.

  4. A villain who for all we know is some one-dimensional guy behind the mask. Nothing to his past, other than having once been a student of the solitary knight character.

That’s the character dynamics of the stand-alone Star Wars film, in a nutshell. I can’t see a story with such characters going beyond a single film.

In The Fellowship of the Ring film, we don’t see the parents or progeny of:

  1. Frodo
  2. Sam
  3. Gandalf
  4. Aragorn
  5. Boromir
  6. Merry
  7. Pippin
  8. Legolas
  9. Gimli

None of the villains had parents that we know of, nor do they have progeny (except for perhaps Sauruman’s weird Orcs).

And yet, I still feel like I can just maybe see the story going beyond a single film.