logo Sign In

Post #112319

Author
iRantanplan
Parent topic
Episode 3: Fan Editing Ideas Discussion
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/112319/action/topic#112319
Date created
6-Jun-2005, 3:35 AM
I can't remember R2 being with Yoda, exept the Clone Wars Cartoon (which aren't canon for me).

Some of you want to delete any reference of Vader in Episode 3. This would create some kind of inconsistence in ANH, when Obi-Wan says to Luke, that Vader killed Anakin. Everyone (especially the first time watchers) would know that Ben is a bad ass liar. So an edit of ANH hope would be nessesary to.

@MagnoliaFan:
I didn't have the chance to see your ATOC edit yet, but there is somethink that bugs me:
Since in the official version Darth Tyrannus is Syfo Dias, who did order the clone army in your version?

Off-Topic:
Yesterday I had a thought. MagnoliaFan, where did a know the name from. Then I remembered: Jay and Silent Bob strike back. Then I thought dude, was the movie inspired by MagnoliaFan, or was MagnoliaFan inspired by the movie.
But after a little thought, there was something that bugged me:
We all know that MagnoliaFan was at a test screening of Episode 3.
We know the name MagnoliaFan was in Jay and Silent Bob strike back.
We know there was some rumors Kevin Smith had done one of the phantom edits himself.
And we know that Kevin Smith was at a test screening of Episode 3.
Maybe it was the insomnia, but isn't it obvious that MagnoliaFan IS INDEED Kevin Smith