If you think the suggestions for ROTJ:R so far are “pushing” Ady to go too far, you must not have been around for the ANH:R and ESB:R threads early on…
Point being, we throw a bunch of shit at the wall and Ady has proven he has a good head for taking the good suggestions and leaving the shit where it belongs. But sometimes you don’t know of something is good or shit until you throw it out there.
(To be fair, I wasn’t in the ANH:R thread until after its release, but I’ve read through most of the early pages by now.)
Makes sense. There’s no harm in offering politely. The previous releases should indeed prepare people that some of their more drastic suggestions might not make the cut.
Cut that. Cut it cut it cut it - do it. Now.
…
NOW
On the other hand, there are posts like this.