logo Sign In

Post #1097299

Author
DuracellEnergizer
Parent topic
What Special Edition changes (if any) did people like?
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1097299/action/topic#1097299
Date created
12-Aug-2017, 6:39 PM

Quatorz said:

I actually didn’t hate putting Haydn in Return of the Jedi.

Wait: hear me out! Believe me: I’m as shocked as anyone to say this, lol. But when Phantom Menace came out, they released a timeline of the Star Wars universe. Phantom Menace took place 32 years before Star Wars. And Lucas commented on how he changed Anakin to being 9 years old.

Well that means Anakin is 41 years old in Star Wars, and he’s probably-what?-44 or 45 in Return of the Jedi.

When they cast Anakin in Return of the Jedi they cast a contemporary of Alec Guiness. Sebastian Shaw was (if I remember right) in his early seventies when he played Anakin. That’s 30 years older than the character would actually be.

So I think that’s one change that wasn’t actually too bad.

Anakin shouldn’t have been nine years old in TPM, which means he shouldn’t have been in his forties in the OT.

A stupid change made to cater to another stupid change doesn’t negate the stupidity of either.