logo Sign In

Post #109231

Author
Commander Courage
Parent topic
Episode 3: Fan Editing Ideas Discussion
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/109231/action/topic#109231
Date created
26-May-2005, 1:15 PM
Originally posted by: klokwerk
This just randomly occured to me out of nowhere...
and I hope I'm not going off-topic here, but I was thinking about the Vader/Emperor/Bridge shot, and suddenly I thought:

Maybe MagFan is going to reuse that scene, by incorporating it into episode VI, and pretend that they are overlooking the construction of the 2nd death star (not the first)!

However, I am probably just rambling as I am in severe need of sleep... Maybe I dreamed this up... hrmm.

That would be interesting, but wouldn't work for several reasons:
1) The 2nd Death Star skeleton does not look like what we see in RotS. Although it does make more sense construction wise to build it that way, unless someone wants to paint in more skeleton in RotJ, they just wouldn't match up.
2) Where would this scene go? Certainly not at the end of ESB. The end of ANH? That's an intriguing possibility, but the lack of dialogue after all that had just transpired would make it almost pointless.
3) Tarkin. I know he is barely seen, but he is noticable.