I’d love to see somebody attempt a newly choreographed duel scene, should somebody have access to an ANH Vader costume and Obi-Wan’s Jedi robes. Just a couple shots to touch up little flaws and all, if also to make Obi-Wan look more formidable like how he managed to defeat Maul on Rebels.
And even after seeing how Vader took apart all those Rebels on Rogue One, maybe we could have a better duel after all. Dreams are for free I do digress…
I do believe it could work, if done well. But it would have to be done perfectly well, or it would look weird, odd and out of place. I don’t think the costumes are the problem, it is replicating the setting, with propper lights and camera work.
It should fit, but if it´s not 100% right. I would preffer to just leave the scene as it is or improve it some way else.