pittrek said:
but even if he would do something like classic rock, I would still find it annoying. Just like Uhura’s singing in TOS - I love Nichelle and her voice, but it just doesn’t fit to Trek.
What about Seven of Nine’s singing? (see my link above)
Why doesn’t it fit to Trek, You don’t think the songs that Vic was singing would make to the 23rd/24th century?
Long story short - song breaks belong to musicals ( IMHO ).
Doing this:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sjN8WDaPT8k
every once and while does not turn Star Trek into a musical. Vic sang when it made sense to sing. He was a hologram of a nightclub singer and he sang in a hologram of a night club. It is not the same as people suddenly breaking out in song in OPS or the bridge of the Defiant or something like that.