logo Sign In

Post #107793

Author
ricarleite
Parent topic
Episode 3: Fan Editing Ideas Discussion
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/107793/action/topic#107793
Date created
23-May-2005, 9:09 AM
For everyone considering editing Episode 3:

I don't know about you, but I think the scene with Owen and Beru looking at the suns, and the scene with the Emperor, vader and Tarkin should switch places, being the later scene the last one, with the closing credits over it. Why? Well, it is obvious to me that the scene with tarkin and vader on the star destroyer bridge looking at the construction of the death star is supposed to happen a few years before Luke is born. I've mentioned in another thread that Palpatine couldn't have done all those uniforms beforehand, and couldn't have recruited so many people. Also, he would only be able to begin the death star AFTER he declared the galactic empire... So it should be Owen and beru looking at the suns, then cut to the ancient-looking TIEs passing by and Vader, the Emperor and Takin looking at the death star. Cut to the side close-up of Vader, then cut back to the death star, seeing Vader from behind (in a similar ending to ESB), and then cut to credits. What do you think?