logo Sign In

Help Wanted: for my Star wars prequel edit.

Author
Time
 (Edited)

Hello everyone! a couple months ago I called for a collaborative fanedit for the star wars prequels I got a couple people on board but I need more volunteers anyone willing to help?

(Here’s Recap of what I posted in November for those who don’t know what I’m talking about.)

"Howdy! My name is Michael but my friends call me Olobby. I’m a huge star wars fan which is why i joined this website. I love the original trilogy and I love what Disney is doing with their movies now but I HATE the prequels. I found a couple edits on this website but they don’t seem to fix the major problems of the movies. Which is why I decided to edit the star wars prequels but my editing skills are awful which is why I’m calling for help for a huge collab. I’ve pitched ideas to edit to my friends and they all love my ideas but can’t edit themselves. I’m open to collab with as many people as possible the more the merrier if you want to help please reply. There’s no commitment you’re free to leave when ever you please. "

Author
Time

I’m down for if it’s possible. What you planning to do with them?

Current Edits:
Obi-Wan Kenobi - TBC
The Mandalorian (Season 1) - V1 Complete
The Mandalorian II (Season 2) - TBC
The Mandalorian Returns (TBOBF) - TBC

Author
Time

Kanemedhurst said:

I’m down for if it’s possible. What you planning to do with them?

I got a couple ideas I’m playing with but here’s one of the main ones. At the end of revenge of the sith Darth Vader lets out his infamous no after he finds out padme is dead many edits I’ve seen just take out this scene but what they don’t understand is by them taking it out they are making the scene end abruptly. Darth Vader just standing up after he finds out his wife is dead is werid. He has to say something or at least do something. I was thinking we can replace Darth Vader’s no with another sound .You most likely asking yourself “like what?” Well I went web surfing and the remembered In the movie lion king mufusa falls to his death letting out a bone chilling scream mufusa is played by james earl jones who also does the voice of darth vader I was thinking we replace that no with the lion king scream. I ran a couple tests on my computer an it matches almost perfectly I just need more editors so what do you think?

Author
Time

The idea of replacing Vaders scream with Mufasas sounds pretty interesting, and I like it, but isnt the scream of Mufasa too short for Vaders scene?

I don’t really care if it’s in the shape of a movie, or a cartoon tv-series, or if it’s on videogames and books. Neither if it’s canon or legends; I love all my Star Wars (yes, even the prequels).

“Laugh it up, Fuzz ball.”

Oh wait, no, not all of it, don’t count the Holiday Special on it.

Author
Time

That’s an interesting idea. I think Mufasa’s scream is too short as Simba’s scream cuts in over it, but you might be able to pass that off as a kind of force scream like Rey hears in the dream sequence in TFA. Would you mind uploading a demo of the scream you’ve been working on?

Author
Time

Edezio Enk’or Valorum said:

The idea of replacing Vaders scream with Mufasas sounds pretty interesting, and I like it, but isnt the scream of Mufasa too short for Vaders scene?

No it’s long enough I just need to edit out the music and simbas no but I can’t my editing skills suck thats why I need help. lol

Author
Time

Imhotep said:

That’s an interesting idea. I think Mufasa’s scream is too short as Simba’s scream cuts in over it, but you might be able to pass that off as a kind of force scream like Rey hears in the dream sequence in TFA. Would you mind uploading a demo of the scream you’ve been working on?

I can’t buddy. Far to busy But I can tell you this. Vader’s scream is about 3 seconds long mufasa scream is about 5 long simbas voice drowns it out near the end. I can fit I just need someone with good editing skills I got a few friends but they are busier than I am. You know anybody?

Author
Time

Can you give us a full proposed cut list. I can’t tell what your vision for the story is so it’s kind of hard to help out.

The task of Vader’s No scream replacement is going to be pretty difficult to do and produce anything that will be clear enough for a final mix.

Do you need this scene? There are some scenes in Field of Dreams where he is angry when Frank first knocks on his
door if you’re looking for something for him to say.

digmodification.wordpress.com

Author
Time

Not my shot to call, but there’s no way to make that scene good. Him screaming is better, but every edit I’ve ever seen where he screams sounded cheesy as hell. I recommend cutting it.

Reading R + L ≠ J theories