logo Sign In

Post #107498

Author
MeBeJedi
Parent topic
Episode 3: Fan Editing Ideas Discussion
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/107498/action/topic#107498
Date created
22-May-2005, 12:00 PM
"And you really must change the title? "

Rikter, you don't like the title "Revenge of the Sith"? (or is this MagnoliaFan's "creative decision". )

"I'm not that bothered by Vader's NOOOOOO. After all, 20 years have passed when we see him in ANH. It's the stumbling that got me. Still, even then I can understand the "getting use to his new limbs" angle."

Wow, and I'm completely the opposite. The stumbling made perfect sense, but the "Nooo" sucked. Every other grunt and yell Vader (JEJ) gives in ESB and ROTJ is great. Too bad he never says anything of the kind in the OT, so that Lucas could copy/paste it (i.e. "Bring me my shuttle.")

"I'm also weighing things like if the Qui-Gon scene is not on the dvd, should I cut the reference altogether and the one in II, or finish the Qui-Gon scene myself."

I'm wondering about how the fake "Qui-gon" screen shot was created. That would be an excellent effect to use on existing video. Recreating the dialogue is something else (unless you just had Qui-gon standing behind Yoda while Yoda is talking to Obi-wan about him. )