Sign In

Post #1073784

Author
regularjoe
Parent topic
Rogue One: The Battle of Scarif fan edit (Released)
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1073784/action/topic#1073784
Date created
6-May-2017, 2:15 PM
Last modified
6-May-2017, 2:17 PM
Edited by
regularjoe
Reason for edit
None provided

Very nicely done.
I do have a question, are you thinking of doing a v2.0 of this or is it done?
The music is nice, I personally am fine with the original score however this is a nice take on it.
The reason I am asking is that the jumping from story arc to story arc could be tightened up even more. For example, there’s three shortish scenes of Jyn and Cassian having a shootout at the records tower as they try to hang on, currently they’re individual scenes and if you combine them the scene plays out quite well. The first two scenes are able to be recut together fairly easily, the last one needs help with the music transitions which you’ve ably demonstrated your skill with.
I’ve taken a crack at consolidating as many scenes as possible, not cutting for the sake of cutting instead the goal being a movie where there isn’t so much cutting back and forth so if it is watched before A New Hope the editing styles feel a little closer than they currently exist.
The music cues in this one are a bear, though.