logo Sign In

Post #1072247

Author
Blacky
Parent topic
The Worst Star Wars Characters
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1072247/action/topic#1072247
Date created
2-May-2017, 9:35 AM

Ryan McAvoy said:

Blacky said:

Ryan McAvoy said:

Blacky said:

Jar-Jar… For sure !!! Can’t think about a worst character in the whole saga…

You might think so on face value but Jar-Jar (largely) isn’t in AOTC and ROTS and many people seem to “prefer” TPM to those two.

I don’t understand your comment. I don’t know anybody who likes Jar-Jar… It’s not because of Jar-Jar if people prefer TPM… It could be a better movie without this poor guy…

Not “because of”, “in spite of”. I was suggesting some people can tolerate Jar-Jar but cannot tolerate creepy serial-killer Anakin (Personally, I do think Jar-Jar is so bad that he makes TPM irredeemable).

Point being, if you replaced PT Anakin with endearing/heroic/charming OT Luke in AOTC, it’d probably become a moderately enjoyable (if flawed) movie. If you replaced Jar-Jar in TPM, with OT Chewie, that movie would still be horrible.

Ok Ryan, I understand now… And I fully agree with you 😉