Amano said:
Many things looked genericI mean, Doug Chiang and Ryan Church are pretty well respected.
And they are wonderful artists. But that didn’t stop most of the designs in the final product from looking dull or “un-starwarsy”. There were a few good designs throughout the PT, but most of it was blah.
I disagree. I always found the OT dull in its design, with things like Han’s ship supposedly looking like a piece of junk compared to other ships not really ringing true when so many of the ships in the OT were the same colorless grey, mega-greebled things, (star destroyers, nebulon frigates, ESB transports etc) or weren’t particularly more sleek looking than the Falcon (X-Wings, B-Wings, Ties, etc).
Felt very same-y to me.