logo Sign In

Post #1071578

Author
Chlorine
Parent topic
Why Didn't Qui Gon Gin's Body Disappear Like Obiwan's and Yoda's?
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1071578/action/topic#1071578
Date created
30-Apr-2017, 7:46 PM

Jaitea said:

Chlorine said:

Jaitea said:

Chlorine said:

Jaitea said:

Yep,…but he hadn’t figured it out yet so he crammed it in along with the Plagus thing

J

And now you’ve moved the goalposts.
You said he forgot. I provided proof that he didn’t.

same thing

j

Not even close. I proved your original claim objectively wrong. We’re done here.

The point is George crammed it in,…whether he forgot or thought he had plenty of time to explain the vanishing trick…he ran out of time & tried to tie up heaps of loose ends in his final episode,…contradicting himself all over the place…now if you want to draw out my ‘forgot’ statement as though Geordie had some master plan,…we all know he didn’t…he makes it up as he goes

j

???
I literally just proved to you that he

  1. put Qui-Gon’s voice in AotC with Yoda
    and
  2. Had it on his mind from 1999.

I’d say the ROTS resolution is perfectly reasonable. Really can’t see an angle where Yoda’s talk with Kenobi about Qui-Gon is unclear or contradictory.