I like these edits though if I can nitpick. I would have loved it if all the 90’s cgi that he’s keeping in these edits would have been updated to modern standards. Cgi has come a long since then that’s why with today’s cgi it would be awesome.
I think most people agree that it looks pretty dated. Updating it all to today’s Hollywood standards would be an extremely expensive endeavor (thousands or millions of dollars).
Most of the CGI in the battle of yavin, for example, can be replaced with models for a more realistic look.