Post #106898

Author: ricarleite
Parent topic: How do you rate EpIII?
Link to post in topic: https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/106898/action/topic#106898
Date created: 20-May-2005, 7:14 AM

As a film: 7/10, it was actually entertaining, slow in some points but I enjoy slow films, almost well acted, almost well written.

As a Star Wars episode: 5/10, still have the same flaws from the prequels, and some new ones. An enjoyable beggining, a few surprises throught the movie, some nice scenes, but that's it.

The 1st is the best, 6th is the worse:

1- ESB
2- ANH
3- ROTJ (very close to ANH)
4- ROTS
5- AOTC
6- TPM