logo Sign In

Post #1064699

Author
DominicCobb
Parent topic
Should the Prequels be more included into the franchise going forward?
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1064699/action/topic#1064699
Date created
11-Apr-2017, 11:53 AM

CatBus said:

DominicCobb said:

Anyway, even if it was as extinct as lightsabers and such, what’s to stop Kylo Ren from considering bringing it back? If he already has a lightsaber, why not a clone army?

I was operating under the assumption that people don’t stop doing things without reason. They clearly stopped making lightsabers because blasters were simply more effective, albeit less elegant (from the available evidence, I have to agree with Han on that score). They stopped cloning for less clear reasons, but there was a war over it, and it’s safe to assume that the clones were on the losing side because none are around by Star Wars, so maybe the clones just didn’t live up to their military potential. In my mind, clones and lightsabers both represent the technological dead ends of the distant past, long since surpassed, with nothing but their nostalgic glow keeping them worth talking about–and that’s at the beginning of Star Wars, let alone three films later.

And yes, Luke can take out a whole sail barge full of blaster-wielding opponents with his lightsaber. But I doubt a lightsaber in the hands of a non-Jedi would be very effective (your three foot range will eventually bite you), and I suspect a Jedi who gave up lightsabers and set his mind to mastering the blaster would be formidable, if considerably less cool-looking. And how many spaceships were outfitted with lightsabers vs blasters? Blasters won the day, long ago. Lightsabers only get points for style.

I still think you’re inferring a lot that isn’t necessarily there.

Lightsabers are a bit different because they are explicitly called Jedi weapons and the of course the Jedi are said to be extinct (and also we know that in our history swords were supplanted by firearms). Literally the only thing we know about clones were that there was a war to do with them and it was some time ago. Anything beyond that is purely a personal extrapolatation you came up with. And personal extrapolations are okay but to take them as a point of fact of the galaxy is where the silliness comes in I think. There’s literally nothing we’re told about clones that preclude them from still being around or even just a possibility.