I agree, they should give Giacchino another chance for a future Star Wars film. His Rogue One score did sound amateurish at times…like it was for an expensive fan film or something.
I’d like him to get another chance - with a little more time to get his work in (was it a month in total for him to do Rogue One?)
Anyway, really liked that snippet from your Edit - you can really see the work you’ve put into it with the 3 sections in your linked video - very much looking forward to seeing more 😃