logo Sign In

Post #1060465

Author
MalàStrana
Parent topic
Clone Wars Movie Series [Episodes I to V released; Episode IX: The Fallen Apprentice now Complete!]
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1060465/action/topic#1060465
Date created
29-Mar-2017, 4:16 PM

“breakdown” of your third edit, Children of the Force. Very fun to rewatch, I didn’t like it at first because I don’t like Bane’s plots but in this context with a few silly things removed and a fast-paced narrative it really works very well.

Here are a few suggestions (not that much since you’ve improved with each new installment of your Clone Wars movies series) that could, IMHO, improve some parts:

Crawl:
Missing “…” at the end of the text.

Audio glitches (4):

  • around 0:15:12
  • around 0:57:30 (“the separatist brought tanks to exterminate us”)
  • around 1:12:01 (“more freedom than I should have”)
  • around 2:14:13

Useless/repetitive dialogues (3):

  • at 0:43:34, the droid lines are repetitive:
    “Sergent, the attack is coming. Prepare for the final attack.”
    Maybe you should correct it as simply: “Sergent, prepare for the final attack.” ?

  • at 02:00:08, Admiral Yularen who doesn’t react quickly to Anakin’s urgent order is something I would suggest to remove: “What happened since the last time we spoke”

  • at 2:14:50: “I’m afraid this installation is lost.” (it’s repetitive with the other dialogues)

Plot issues (2):

  • at 01:11:32, during the Ahsoka library assignement scene, there is a line that betrays the scene was taken from another story arc:
    “is the description of the incident by Obi-Wan accurate ?”. I think you can remove it and the scene would still be understandable. Or just remove the fact Obi-Wan has described an accident he wasn’t even there to witness, like: “Is the description of the accident accurate ?” to imply that Anakin is the one who told how it happened.

  • the Anakin saving the day scene at the senate should be move a little bit forward, after Bane has begun his entrance into the Temple. That’s way it’s more clear for the audience that the senate crisis is a decoy, a deception. Otherwise we don’t quite see the point of such an operation.

Other suggestions:

  • at 1:18:00, unecessary violence when the senate guard is killed (“help me !”)

Anyway, here is a french subtitles file synchonized to your cut: https://mega.nz/#!wx0gRAQK!CRHJ7BNceK1PdBbOnNqdaZaJ9KnkytvbDJyU6tF75Gw