Originally posted by: Darth Mallwalker
Vote early and often. What's to stop somebody from stuffing the ballot box ?
First, you have to be a member and logged in to vote. Second, as far as I know each member can only vote once in a poll. I'm sure some could find a way around that if they wanted to but the only advantage would be to make a set that you had a hand in producing look better. I think that most of the people that put the time and effort in creating these sets for us to enjoy have better things to do than tamper with a poll, like going back to the drawing board and making said set better so that it will fair better against the competition next time. Padding the ballot box is not the way to improve on the quality of your set.
Originally posted by: Karyudo
I feel like maybe this is a poll that should be re-done every month or two; this existing poll should definitely have a defined "shelf life." Like it should be labelled the 2005-05 poll, with results valid only until some new transfers exist and are ready for inclusion, at which point the poll should be closed and superceded.
Vote early and often. What's to stop somebody from stuffing the ballot box ?
First, you have to be a member and logged in to vote. Second, as far as I know each member can only vote once in a poll. I'm sure some could find a way around that if they wanted to but the only advantage would be to make a set that you had a hand in producing look better. I think that most of the people that put the time and effort in creating these sets for us to enjoy have better things to do than tamper with a poll, like going back to the drawing board and making said set better so that it will fair better against the competition next time. Padding the ballot box is not the way to improve on the quality of your set.
Originally posted by: Karyudo
I feel like maybe this is a poll that should be re-done every month or two; this existing poll should definitely have a defined "shelf life." Like it should be labelled the 2005-05 poll, with results valid only until some new transfers exist and are ready for inclusion, at which point the poll should be closed and superceded.
I definately agree with that statement. It is something that needs to be renewed from time to time. Not only so that you can include new preservation sets but so that members that have expanded their viewing knowledge of the sets get a chance to revoice or change their opinion/vote.