logo Sign In

Post #1058445

Author
imperialscum
Parent topic
Rogue One * Spoilers * Thread
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1058445/action/topic#1058445
Date created
23-Mar-2017, 4:53 PM

Lord Haseo said:

The only one that can really be considered high art is ESB and that’s not to say that SW and TFA aren’t great films but if we compare those films to some of the all time greats they won’t hold up nearly as well as ESB would.

First, what is this “high art” crap anyway? Seem like some irrelevant snobbish thing that does not have any connection to the reality.

When it comes to comparison to other great films, I think ANH is the only one that can stand alone and be compared. Yes, ESB has more complex story and a bit better execution, but its story is completely dependant on the other two films and it builds on many concepts introduced in the original. Not to mention ANH was by far more culturally impactful and historically significant.

and that’s not to say that SW and TFA aren’t great films

Don’t embarrass yourself. It is silly to say TFA is good film, but this is getting beyond ridiculous.