I’m also pondering if it’s okay for people to shit on the OT because of ROTJ…I am extremely incredulous that you would be okay with that. Given your hypocrisy and all.
ROTJ was great while TFA was utter crap. That is a big difference.
ROTJ was good but it was NOTHING in comparison to SW and ESB. TFA is really good imo but it could be garbage in comparison to VIII and IX. So regardless of how you were to phrase it there is still a huge gap in quality depending on your position. For the people who dislike ROTJ could they judge the entirety of the trilogy based on 1 installment?
Yes because even if they judged OT based on ROTJ it would be great. If they judge new trilogy based on TFA, it would be crap.
The people in this scenario would have a generally unfavorable opinion of the OT because of ROTJ so your position is of no consequence. Having said that would they be right to hold that negative opinion?