- Time
- Post link
What did we do this time?
Ranking the Star Wars films — Page 74
- Time
- Post link
Well i’m done.
If a mod sees this, please remove my account and my posts. I thought i would have some good time, discussing SW and meeting new people but i was wrong.
There is no room for personal opinions in here, and if you have one, you are going to have some childish people coming at you.
Take care.
- Time
- (Edited)
- Post link
Well i’m done.
If a mod sees this, please remove my account and my posts. I thought i would have some good time, discussing SW and meeting new people but i was wrong.
There is no room for personal opinions in here, and if you have one, you are going to have some childish people coming at you.
Take care.
If you come back you should consider pointing out specific posts where this has actually happened.
No one said you aren’t welcome to your opinion. No one said your list was stupid (I mean I don’t get your list but you’re welcome to it, it’s your opinion). No one said only the OT movies count (I like TFA and RO both quite a bit).
All I said if you remove the Ewoks then the movie doesn’t work, and that I don’t understand why you have the PT so high and the TFA so low…and you did repsond, kind of, but also threw that in with a bunch of EVERYONE’S BEING MEAN TO ME!!! nonsense that you seem to have anticipated before it actually happened. Seems to me you were expecting a fight, it didn’t happen, so you just proceeded to pick the fight anyway despite no one taking you up on it.
What the heck else can I say but “k” when you introduce yourself to the community this way?
- Time
- (Edited)
- Post link
Ranking of my two posts:
- Original post
- Double post
- Time
- Post link
What did we do this time?
Failed to give him the fight he came here looking for, as far as I can tell. But honestly I have no idea.
- Time
- Post link
If this isn’t the most childish thing I have ever seen in my life…
- Time
- Post link
^ you should try having an actual child… it makes sense that the behavior is named after them.
- Time
- Post link
Apparently this crazy question pushed them over the edge?
Beyond I’d like to know what you loved about ROTS and AOTC while loathing TFA to the point that it’s the worst Star Wars created.
I was curious to what the response would be.
Rankings though; it goes SW, ESB, ROTJ
I know that Empire is deeper and more dramatic, but I just have a thing for Tatooine and the Trench Run. Plus Peter Cushing and Alec Guinness.
- Time
- Post link
Han and Leia were great in TFA.
Where is that Donald Trump “Wrong!” meme at…
- Time
- Post link
Han and Leia were great in TFA.
Where is that Donald Trump “Wrong!” meme at…
What was wrong with their portrayal? They’re the same people we know them from ROTJ with the exception of sharing a loss that has led them to splitting up.
I wish Leia would have became a Jedi though. They fucked up not doing that in my opinion.
- Time
- Post link
My revised list:
- Star Wars
- The Empire Strikes Back
- The Force Awakens
- Return of the Jedi
- Rogue One
- The Star Wars Holiday Special
My thought process was led by a fairly simple question: “Which would I want to watch again right now?”. For me I loved Rogue One and thought it was done very well, but it’s not the kind of movie I would watch over and over.
- Time
- Post link
Han and Leia were great in TFA.
Where is that Donald Trump “Wrong!” meme at…
It is my subjective opinion that Han and Leia were great in TFA.
- Time
- Post link
Han and Leia were great in TFA.
Where is that Donald Trump “Wrong!” meme at…
What was wrong with their portrayal? They’re the same people we know them from ROTJ with the exception of sharing a loss that has led them to splitting up.
I wish Leia would have became a Jedi though. They fucked up not doing that in my opinion.
I’m glad they didn’t do that, personally.
- Time
- Post link
What was wrong with their portrayal? They’re the same people we know them from ROTJ with the exception of sharing a loss that has led them to splitting up.
Leia didn’t really have a role in the movie. She was just “there”. She doesn’t even acknowledge Chewie after Han dies. Instead she’s consoling someone she barely knows because welp, the filmmakers needed to foist some kind of female character connection upon the audience that they weren’t skilled enough to establish in a dramatic way throughout the rest of the movie.
Han was better because he had a legitimate role in the movie, but the role was still more in line with Kingdom of the Crystal Skull bullshit than Star Wars. At no point in the movie did I ever feel like Han Solo was a serious character. He feels like he’s an action figure in a comic book universe.
And I can’t even get started on this whole thing with their supposed son. There is nothing emotional or dramatic about any of it because these people never share a history together on screen. Characters don’t earn those emotions through a few lines of expository dialogue. He’s Han and Leia’s son…because the writers told us. Oh look, he killed Han. How sad! Just no, no, no. That’s not how it works.
- Time
- Post link
It is my subjective opinion that Han and Leia were great in TFA.
That’s fine, and you are entitled to that.
But it is also my subjective opinion that your opinion is wrong.
- Time
- Post link
Alphabetical Order:
Attack of the Clones
Return of the Jedi
Revenge of the Sith
Rogue One
Star Wars
The Empire Strikes Back
The Force Awakens
The Last Jedi
The Phantom Menace
- Time
- Post link
It is my subjective opinion that Han and Leia were great in TFA.
That’s fine, and you are entitled to that.
But it is also my subjective opinion that your opinion is wrong.
People keep saying opinions can’t be wrong so…I guess you mean you disagree with my opinion.
- Time
- (Edited)
- Post link
Alphabetical Order:
Attack of the Clones
Empire Strikes Back, The
Force Awakens, The
Last Jedi, The
Phantom Menace, The
Return of the Jedi
Revenge of the Sith
Rogue One
Star Wars
I tried to fix that for you but AOTC is still first and SW still last. I guess I’ll just say “I improved that a little for you.” Although it moved up TPM too high…so I guess there’s no fixing it.
- Time
- Post link
What was wrong with their portrayal? They’re the same people we know them from ROTJ with the exception of sharing a loss that has led them to splitting up.
Leia didn’t really have a role in the movie. She was just “there”.
She sent Poe to Lor San Tekka and in general her resolve is why The Resistance had any chance to find Luke. She also gave Han hope that their son still had light in him.
She doesn’t even acknowledge Chewie after Han dies. Instead she’s consoling someone she barely knows because welp, the filmmakers needed to foist some kind of female character connection upon the audience that they weren’t skilled enough to establish in a dramatic way throughout the rest of the movie.
They fucked up with the Chewie thing…yes they did. Even JJ admits he was wrong for that. Sucks no one who was around him during filming that told him that having Leia hug Rey is a terrible idea.
Han was better because he had a legitimate role in the movie, but the role was still more in line with Kingdom of the Crystal Skull bullshit than Star Wars. At no point in the movie did I ever feel like Han Solo was a serious character. He feels like he’s an action figure in a comic book universe.
I really don’t know what to say to this one…sorry you feel that way.
And I can’t even get started on this whole thing with their supposed son. There is nothing emotional or dramatic about any of it because these people never share a history together on screen. Characters don’t earn those emotions through a few lines of expository dialogue. He’s Han and Leia’s son…because the writers told us. Oh look, he killed Han. How sad! Just no, no, no. That’s not how it works.
I care about Han, Leia and Luke so that’s why I cared. I care about Ben and Luke in SW so that’s why I was emotionally invested in Ben confronting Darth Vader.
- Time
- Post link
Han and Leia were great in TFA.
Where is that Donald Trump “Wrong!” meme at…
What was wrong with their portrayal? They’re the same people we know them from ROTJ with the exception of sharing a loss that has led them to splitting up.
I wish Leia would have became a Jedi though. They fucked up not doing that in my opinion.
I’m glad they didn’t do that, personally.
Why?
I personally think they should have opted for both. Have Luke train her in the first decade or so post the Battle of Endor then after (insert reason here) she decides to fully invest in Politics/Military.
- Time
- Post link
Leia was a not-Jedi for all three original movies. I don’t think of her as a Jedi, she didn’t think of herself as a Jedi, and it would have been weird for her to suddenly be a Jedi in the fourth movie.
- Time
- Post link
Alphabetical Order:
Attack of the Clones
Empire Strikes Back, The
Force Awakens, The
Last Jedi, The
Phantom Menace, The
Return of the Jedi
Revenge of the Sith
Rogue One
Star WarsI tried to fix that for you but AOTC is still first and SW still last. I guess I’ll just say “I improved that a little for you.” Although it moved up TPM too high…so I guess there’s no fixing it.
Star Wars can be first, if we use A New Hope.
- Time
- Post link
Alphabetical Order:
Attack of the Clones
Empire Strikes Back, The
Force Awakens, The
Last Jedi, The
Phantom Menace, The
Return of the Jedi
Revenge of the Sith
Rogue One
Star WarsI tried to fix that for you but AOTC is still first and SW still last. I guess I’ll just say “I improved that a little for you.” Although it moved up TPM too high…so I guess there’s no fixing it.
Star Wars can be first, if we use A New Hope.
Dammit I missed that.
- Time
- Post link
Han and Leia were perfect in TFA.
- Time
- Post link
Leia was a not-Jedi for all three original movies. I don’t think of her as a Jedi, she didn’t think of herself as a Jedi, and it would have been weird for her to suddenly be a Jedi in the fourth movie.
The 30 year time gaps helps all of these issues both with our perception and Leia’s potential “conflict” regarding embracing being a Jedi.