I’ve spent a long time figuring out exactly what’s wrong with the Blu-ray, which has clipped highlights among other issues. One of the most interesting discoveries is that the highlight data isn’t gone, it just isn’t displayed due to a a blu-ray encoding error. Any attempt to re-encode the movie before editing it will erase this data, so I import the raw stream into Premiere and rescue the highlights with a curves adjustment, which only works because it uses the native YUV stream instead of converting it to RGB like most effects.
TL;DR: Dre’s has clipped highlights, mine does not.