logo Sign In

Episode VIII : The Last Jedi - Discussion * SPOILER THREAD * — Page 30

Author
Time

Mithrandir said:

Still spitting in the face of where the OT ended.

That’s the only way the ST handled the ending of ROTJ wrong.

Author
Time

I thought it handled the ending of ROTJ just fine. I like characters that go through stuff. If they don’t go through stuff, it’s just a documentary, and a bad one at that.

Author
Time

The fact is that TFA was such a train-wreck that the whole trilogy is basically lost. Even though it does not look very promising at this point (another major rehash is hinted) I will give the film a fair chance.

真実

Author
Time

imperialscum said:

The fact is that TFA was such a train-wreck

Lol.

the whole trilogy is basically lost.

I will give the film a fair chance.

Lol.

Author
Time

Well fair chance with all the facts considered. There is no other way.

真実

Author
Time

It’s a fact that you do.

Forum Moderator
Author
Time

It’s a good title (if predictable, remember that one guy who guessed TFA? Lot more than one this time). My only problem with it is that it has the same noun as ROTJ so confusion will begin when referring to the films by just the noun.

TLJ. Nice.

Author
Time

JawsTDS said:

I like it. I also like them staying with their minimalist take on the teaser. Red logo, white copy for the title. No complaints here.

Forum Moderator
Author
Time

TV’s Frink said:

I like characters that go through stuff. If they don’t go through stuff, it’s just a documentary, and a bad one at that.

Exactly. There’s nothing in ROTJ that states everything would be peaceful and nice for the rest of eternity so I don’t see people’s problem. Even though I’m fine with how the ST opens I would have preferred to have everything be peaceful so we can enjoy the tranquility so that everything can turn to shit in front of our very eyes.

Author
Time
 (Edited)

I actually quite like the title. It has a very nice and minimalist quality to it, but a lot of layers as well.

So… which Jedi? Plural Jedi? One Jedi? Historically? Presently?

Luke? Rey? Ben? Another?

Hmmm…

Spoiler: It’s Luke.

Also I’m probably going to exit this thread now until the movie is released.

Keep Circulating the Tapes.

END OF LINE

(It hasn’t happened yet)

Author
Time

I dig the title.
It’s simple and epic all at once.

Well my days of not taking you seriously are certainly coming to a middle.

Author
Time

Last Week, on Jedi

The credits will end with “What happens next? Find out in two years! Same Star Week, same Star Theater!”

.

Author
Time

The title seems pretty boring to me, but the quality of the title rarely says much about the quality of the movie, so we’ll see. I expect to enjoy it more than TFA, since there’s less room for rehashing (I would think). I’ve only seen TFA once, though, and I’d gladly watch it again, given the opportunity, to see if my opinion changes after a second viewing.

Author
Time
 (Edited)

If the last Jedi is Luke we will defo see an ESB rehash with Luke training Rey ffs!

No doubt Luke will be killed by kylo ren yawn. And Rey will watch him get killed!

Author
Time

IP55 said:

If the last Jedi is Luke we will defo see an ESB rehash with Luke training Rey ffs!

No doubt Luke will be killed by kylo ren yawn. And Rey will watch him get killed!

So… uh… should Luke not train anyone? Should Rey not become a Jedi? Or are you just trolling?

Keep Circulating the Tapes.

END OF LINE

(It hasn’t happened yet)

Author
Time

Tyrphanax said:

IP55 said:

If the last Jedi is Luke we will defo see an ESB rehash with Luke training Rey ffs!

No doubt Luke will be killed by kylo ren yawn. And Rey will watch him get killed!

So… uh… should Luke not train anyone? Should Rey not become a Jedi? Or are you just trolling?

Forum Moderator

Where were you in '77?

Author
Time
 (Edited)

Tyrphanax said:

IP55 said:

If the last Jedi is Luke we will defo see an ESB rehash with Luke training Rey ffs!

No doubt Luke will be killed by kylo ren yawn. And Rey will watch him get killed!

So… uh… should Luke not train anyone? Should Rey not become a Jedi? Or are you just trolling?

Luke should definitely train Jedi and Rey should become a Jedi. But not in a rehash way.

Luke is in hiding. Luke being the last of the Jedi. Rey goes find Luke to get trained. By the book rehash of ESB.

To be fair, this rehash was primarily perpetrated by TFA.

真実

Author
Time

Le Dernier Jedi ?
Les Derniers Jedi ?
La Dernière Jedi ?
The Last Thursday ?

Spoiler alert when the translations come. But I believe there is no ambiguity, it refers to Luke and that’s all.

Author
Time

imperialscum said:

Tyrphanax said:

IP55 said:

If the last Jedi is Luke we will defo see an ESB rehash with Luke training Rey ffs!

No doubt Luke will be killed by kylo ren yawn. And Rey will watch him get killed!

So… uh… should Luke not train anyone? Should Rey not become a Jedi? Or are you just trolling?

Luke should definitely train Jedi and Rey should become a Jedi. But not in a rehash way.

Luke is in hiding. Luke being the last of the Jedi. Rey goes find Luke to get trained. By the book rehash of ESB.

To be fair, this rehash was primarily perpetrated by TFA.

I think Episode 8 won’t be a rehash, because there isn’t enough left material to rehash.

Author
Time

MalàStrana said:

imperialscum said:

Tyrphanax said:

IP55 said:

If the last Jedi is Luke we will defo see an ESB rehash with Luke training Rey ffs!

No doubt Luke will be killed by kylo ren yawn. And Rey will watch him get killed!

So… uh… should Luke not train anyone? Should Rey not become a Jedi? Or are you just trolling?

Luke should definitely train Jedi and Rey should become a Jedi. But not in a rehash way.

Luke is in hiding. Luke being the last of the Jedi. Rey goes find Luke to get trained. By the book rehash of ESB.

To be fair, this rehash was primarily perpetrated by TFA.

I think Episode 8 won’t be a rehash, because there isn’t enough left material to rehash.

That hasn’t hindered you any.