logo Sign In

Post #1036053

Author
Ronster
Parent topic
Neverar's A New Hope Technicolor Recreation (Final Version Released!)
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1036053/action/topic#1036053
Date created
19-Jan-2017, 11:43 AM

towne32 said:

Ronster said:

nope the panels are not green, all of the green is at the bottom end of the color spectrum and green being the most luminous color would not act like this.

by the laws of physics it’s impossible.

You mean this color spectrum?

I don’t really mean to be antagonistic but, well, you’re being pretty damn antagonistic in this thread. I’m not sure why you’ve become a color expert overnight. You’re arguing about physics you surely can’t back in this thread, and you’ve started another thread where you stole the work from someone else’s color correction and claimed it as your own.

And this is coming from someone that agrees with you about the green. I don’t like it aesthetically, and I think it’s bizarre that prints look like they do. Hell, green and yellow color throughout SW 2.5 compelled me to spend a huge amount of my time tweaking it. But let’s not make claims we can’t back…

No I worked with Lighting for a lot of years. Green is in the middle spectrum right. Red is right up the other end of the Spectrum to the right. That means that it has no chance of Punching through the green light so precisely from a reflection. It would punch through if the light was pointing straight at it.

It could be lit a gentle cyan gel allowing a lot of white light through but definitely not green or any sort of Lime is a bit of a stretch there.

I am not being antagonistic at all sorry If I am coming across that way. I honestly think it’s a mistake. I am not a color correction expertise extraordinaire, but I am pointing out that it’s definitely not lit green. I am trying to be helpful. I don’t know if you like or agree with what I am saying though.

If you want to believe it’s lit green I don’t mind.

Was this not the same print with the mint green walls all over the Tantive IV?

So basically by this pattern of thought all the lights had green gels in them?

I mean by power of deduction I am not sure how this is debated as some sort of mystery for so long, personally I think it is a problem with the print. If everything is green it’s unlikely the LD decided to light everything green no matter what environment they were in?

I think you can reproduce the colors of a print for fun or you may as well just have a guess and go about trying to fix it and make it look acceptable and enjoyable.

I think that is really the solution.

I don’t know the answer it does not look right though. So it probably is not right. Hold on to that.