IP55 said:
Lord Haseo said:
IP55 said:
ROTJ for all its problems has the real vader and the emperor.
R1’s Vader acted more like his incarnations in SW and ESB than his ROTJ counterpart. I agree on Palpy though.
Those final scenes are epic. Nothing ib these spin offs can match the OT…and they never will.
How come OT.com keeps getting members who can see into the future and why am I not one of them?
R1s Vader was better than the shitty pre prequel Vader but still, even Jedi Vader didn’t say those stupid lines! That is not what an OT Vader would have said.
I think lines like “I find your lack of faith disturbing” and “Perhaps you think you’re being treated unfairly.” would have criticized had they been in this film. I can imagine people ripping the former line apart under the pretense that the Force is more than just a belief system.
Or his half arsed choke hold!
It’s a few centimeters for God’s sake…
but to others the space between his fingers could be a mile. But I’m just going to let the images speak for themselves.
I am judging future films on what I have already seen. R1 is the closest so far but not quite right!
Not a line of thought I would follow as different film makers are going to bring different things to the films they write and direct.