Anyone who ranks any of the new films above the OT is wrong. ROTJ for all its problems has the real vader and the emperor. Those final scenes are epic. Nothing ib these spin offs can match the OT…and they never will. The OT was done in a time where Frank Oz and Co created some majestic, mythological classics. Think Labyrinth, dark crystal and even Willow they all had a timeless feel that evokes memories and fantastical worlds. These new films are easily forgotten and do not evoke any of the afore mentioned.