To each their own but I don’t see how anyone could feel Rogue One (or The Force Awakens for that matter) are better films than Jedi.
I prefer ROTJ to Rogue One but that film has better action, dialogue, directing and a far better 3rd act but I will admit that ROTJ trumps Rogue One in a big as it pertains it pertains to plot and characters. I was more emotionally invested and entertained with a watered down Han than I was with most of the Rogue One characters.
I don’t think I need to state why I think TFA is better than ROTJ.
EDIT:
Some people really hate Jedi though.
I think Jedi is…okay.
I think we have different definitions of “okay” because I find ROTS to be okay whereas I find ROTJ to still be quite good despite the myriad of issues I have with it. I just have too much fun with the film to rate it anything lower than a 7.
No, we have just different opinions on the quality of the two movies. Especially ROTS, which I think is anything but “okay.”
That too but I’m sure you’d rate ROTJ no lower than a 7/10 and I consider that score to be an indication of a good film. 5-6/10 is what I would deem an okay film.