The Rogue One battle was put together much better than the last battle in TFA, I will give it that. But dramatically it still doesn’t compare to any of the originals in my opinion. I think it’s a tone and approach thing. Just watch the Battle of Yavin or the Battle of Hoth. They are acted and shot and edited like they are real military battles. Rogue One and TFA feel much more like they are battles that happen in a Marvel Superhero universe. They seem more like comic book fights to me.