I am surprised that only one point I had against the film has been the focus here. The main sin Rogue One commits is that it’s just boring to me.

Fan film and fan service, etc., are slurs only in the case of a huge feature film. We generally expect different things from something from a fan than from filmmakers. It goes along the same line of thinking where in response to people saying the Despecialized Editions should be official, Harmy saying he’d be outraged. Because he expects better.