logo Sign In

Post #1022714

Author
ZkinandBonez
Parent topic
Rogue One * Spoilers * Thread
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1022714/action/topic#1022714
Date created
22-Dec-2016, 4:18 PM

Ronster said:

ZkinandBonez said:

And as for the main characters abandoning Saw’s men to die. I noticed while watching the film that all of his men had disappeared to somewhere before K-2SO showed up with the U-Wing.

I was also paying extra close attention to Vader’s speech during his first appearance this time around. I don’t really have too much to add, other than that I personally can’t hear anything wrong with it other than that James Earl Jones doesn’t quite have that extra punch in his voice anymore (which is to be expected at his age). But I honestly can’t find the big flaws in his dialogue or the incorrect voice modulation that some people are talking about. I honestly couldn’t hear it. I’m not doubting that it is ever so slightly different, after all imitating analogue sound editing form the 70’s can’t be too easy, but I fail to hear anything overly wrong with it.
(PS. Most of the redness of his eyes are reflections from the red lights in his lair, not from the eyes themselves.)

I also agree that there wasn’t really much to suggest to Vader that the rebel at the end of the hallway had the DS plans. Vader’s only goal was to get into the ship before it escaped.

Just FYI you can see the Partisans group around some X-wing’s briefly (with the black & white paint job) during the Death Star firing at the city you do not however see them leave and you don’t unfortunately see them show up on Scarif. Those scenes were cut.

True. I guess canonically they escaped in their own ships despite it never being shown in the film. It’s the kind of detail that I guess would only annoy, or even be noticed, by fans like us. Most people probably never even thought about that they disappeared.